Power meters for idiots

Am I missing something here :face_with_peeking_eye::roll_eyes:
If you drop to 46 on your left side, which is where the PM measures, then the PM simply doubles it to 92 so not 3-5% really.

Say you drift on effort over the last 40-60km …
You’ve targeted to do 225W, but your PM is telling you 207W, so you increase your effort until it says 225W, but you might actually be doing 245W.

So you’ve overcooked it. Massively.

Yes I would be close to ~8% off at my absolute worst on those numbers, but what I meant was 99% of my riding I’d be within 5% (and the majority within 2%).
The only time I’ve seen something like 46.5-47.0 on the Left is in the final minutes of something like a VO2 session, not prolonged 50km.

But if you’ve know that your L/R changes in different conditions, then that’s when it becomes less useful. In my example I wouldn’t know if I was losing watts as a I fatigue or just shifting towards my right leg.

1 Like

I didn’t realise until after I’d ordered it, but my new bike comes with a SRAM crank-based power meter as standard.

I’ve never used a power meter on the road before, only on Zwift and a wattbike. I doubt if it’ll be much more than another number on the Garmin for me, but it’ll still be interesting to see what my outdoor power looks like :man_shrugging:

5 Likes

It’s not one of these that you need to pay to actually use it?

1 Like

Let us know :slight_smile:

IMO it’s only interesting to review for racing and workouts. I’d say I benefitted from practising steady (ish), tempo power on climbs.

I’m trying outdoor workouts a lot more at the moment.

It’ll be staying deactivated for now at least if it is :roll_eyes:. It’s a bonus feature for me and not one that I’d pay extra for.

2 Likes

I wouldn’t have thought so. It’ll be a quarq under the hood too (even if officially sram branded) so should be about as good as they get.

Surprises me you’ve not had one for outdoors before. For random road riding, I’d agree with others the numbers aren’t critical but there are points in a ride when they help like others have said. And over time, I do think having the data better evaluates cumulative stress and trends.

3 Likes

Any experts have an opinion of Garmin Rally vs Assioma? Both dual sided, same price and both SPD-SL. Bike computer and watch are both Garmin if that makes a difference.

1 Like

Assioma’s are better.

Cooler kids buy them.

Sciencefact

8 Likes

If you have other Garmin stuff, I’d go Rally especially if you can get them the same price. That’s what I have.

Ultimately, Rally looks way cleaner than the Assioma’s in my opinion, and if you’re going for spd-sl then the Assioma’s is a bit of a bastardisation to make them. They’re not the same Keo equivalent pedal…the Q-factor is more as they sort of fudged the old tech into a spd-sl pedal body. Plus, the old issues of torque wrenches for Vector is gone with Rally.

As ever, DCR has all the full details. But the one thing I’d say there is the price…back when he wrote that, Rally was c50% more expensive. That was always the Assioma’s plus point. If price difference isn’t there, I don’t see why you’d go for them.

2 Likes

See above

3 Likes

Why do you want power?

Send me Ā£400 and I’ll send you some numbers after every ride for you to look at.

Sorted. :white_check_mark:

You’re going to do some rides and get a number.
Look at it.
Shrug. And repeat.

Waste of money.

3 Likes

A fair question

Excessively presumptuous!

2 Likes

Why do you want an overpriced tshirt with Palace written on it? Or whatever the brand of the day is?!

So many Why’s! :joy:

9 Likes

To keep Lev in business :white_check_mark:
Supreme bought out by Luxotica yesterday.

Anyways, this is power meters for idiots.
Idiots shouldn’t waste money on power meters.

Ride your bike. Have fun. Don’t be a slave to the numbers. Learn how to pop a wheelie. Do a sweet skid coming into T2. Drink some beetroot juice and sit in the garage with the door closed and engine running. It’s all good.

Not sure how one why is so many? :woman_shrugging:t2:

2 Likes

Well my why is why can’t you ride to numbers, build structured plans to improve if you gain happiness and satisfaction from goals and stuff. Why is it one or the other?

I have a power meter (as do you! :joy:) and it doesn’t diminish my fun.

I wear a garmin on long trail runs. I keep an eye on pace and stuff. But it doesn’t take away my enjoyment. But it does help me improve.

It’s all about the grey my Poetic friend.

8 Likes

Ok, I’m sorry, I’ve ditched the idea of buying a power meter, if you can send me bank details I’ll set up a direct debit for the power numbers. If you could make my normalised power for Thursday night club TTs in the mid-300s it would be appreciated. :wink:

I’ve used the money I saved to get a new bike instead, it’s a Sledgehammer with shocks, pegs and I’ll be taking it off some sweet jumps later on. :grin:

9 Likes

I always liked one of Alex Dowsett’s quotes when talking about kids cycling, ā€œDont buy a power meter, buy a BMX insteadā€

5 Likes