Strava

Giving strava due respect, the presentation of segments in Garmin Connect is nothing on what strava can do.

I’ve created a new segment based on one I run regularly. It was problematic to pick the precisely correct start and end points. Once created, it now seems I would have to go back through each and every one of my relevant runs to get the data from those to be matched against the segment. Otherwise, only runs completed going forward would be matched against them.

Representation of the runs is also much worse. Just a small box list, that’s not easy to navigate.

Not a patch on strava’s segment presentation.

I’m happy to acknowledge strava do this stuff very well. Will I be prepared to pay for it. Time will tell

4 Likes

Im no surprised with the “Strava might not exist” comment, as much as its nice I cant imagine them offering anything Id pay for.

Maybe some kind of club aubscription would work for them?

I’ve pretty much agreed with all your posts on this topic @stenard as they’ve closely reflected my own thoughts.

But that’s it in a nutshell for me.

1 Like

that segment comparison is AWESOME!

You can see where you gain and lose time on your “rivals” (they’re better uphill, slower on downhill, take more risks at the junction, but lose time on the back stretch home)

Okay, that is pretty damn decent.

Which one do you mean?

One thing that is still there is flyby comparison. Which is one of the things I’ve used most in the past to compare races to friends. For example, a recent zwift race:

1 Like

Yeah - although mine doesn’t look like that.

I’m not sure which one you are talking about? The above screenshot is from flyby comparisons. The prior screenshot was from the old “my results” graph of a given segment

The lower one.
I see a leaderboard and can select people I’m following. I’ve never used it before, as you can only use it on a laptop. Just had a quick look on my laptop for a “missing” 3rd place, after their support told me to change the activity type to CANOE, refresh achievements, change back to bike - I am now showing as 3rd on the segment :smiling_imp:

The lower one is from full activity flybys. It’s nothing to do with segment analysis

Okay, on my activity, I click on the “View All” rosette for segments and see this:

I then click on the highlighted segment and see this:

If I then click on “Compare”, I see the Effort Analysis:

There’s no mention of “Fly-Bys” anywhere ???

Flybys is for a full activity, not for segments.

1 Like

To see all that you now need premium.
Flybys is on the web, underneath the activity title
image

1 Like

Ah - yes, I’m on a free trial, so can see the effort/segment analysis.

I had to google FlyBy, as I couldn’t for the life of me see that link!!!

Anyone having garmin to strava sync issues this morning?

I’m not sure if it’s a rollover from the fact I used to have all leaderboards set to “my results” by default, but the desktop version of strava is still showing my personal top 10 rather than the overall top 10 for me, despite the drop down menu displaying “overall”. That’s a nice little bonus for now.

Without that, I actually had my first example of where I might want to pay for strava, even if I only for every now and then reasons. On my ride this morning, I wanted to check just how the indoor riding had impacted me. Similar to how Matt has mentioned for him. Box Hill is one of the only known segments where I have, over time, repeatedly attempted pretty hard efforts.

Thankfully, the (likely unintended) results I’m seeing saved me having to search back through past rides for past efforts. A pretty huge PB. Shows there’s definitely been some benefit to the zwifting!

292w today with 172 ave HR. Previous PB from last year was 262w with 165 ave HR. It shows the dramatic increase in my 5min power from zwifting has transferred outside. I also noticed on other climbs that I felt like I was spinning up, 230 odd watts was relatively comfortable and I was surprised to see those numbers. Last year, that was a borderline threshold effort.

3 Likes

Meanwhile I felt like I was dragging a sled up Salcombe Hill! :man_facepalming:t3:

Turns out it was just my jiggly gut! :joy:

1 Like

Have they restricted access to your training log as well? I can see it in the background but it’s offering a trial or learn more.

Yeah i don’t see my log, with the bubbles every week now. I have signed up to free version of TP though.

Any idea how I get all my past data in there? Quick Web searches not bringing much back.

It actually looks like it’s been improved and you get a full screen view on a PC.

Have you tried connecting training peaks to Garmin Connect? Not sure it will pull in the old data though?