Most Overrated Piece of Training Equipment

Twat :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

2 Likes

How about a temporary tattoo of the splits for a seven hour marathon?

2 Likes

This might actually be useful for me for next Saturday :sob::laughing:

10 Likes

Pull Buoy and Tri Bike hardly in the same league for over-ratedness. I’d say a Tri Bike is appropriately rated, given the difference to a road bike on a flat course.

Salt is a funny one. I’m all for the science that says it’s pointless and unrelated. I’m glad you discovered that aspect of human physiology 5 years ago and taught the world that.

Cramps are undeniably fatigue related.
But it’s interesting there are so many advocates, people who absolutely swear by salt. Yes placebo ± marketing is powerful, but there’s not many products people will die on the hill for like they will for salt in preventing cramps, so who knows maybe there is a subset of people for whom there’s something there :person_shrugging:
Again maybe it’s placebo. But for some people it clearly works like nothing else. I’d be interested in seeing those people go through a blinded trial

6 Likes

Might be wrong, but I thinks it’s science Stenard who swears by salt?

Anytime! :sweat_smile:

1 Like

I think there is something in electrolyte replacement helping slow down the onset of cramping, but no doubt linked to increased fatigue being caused by dehydration, rather than lack of salt being the primary issue

A lot of swimmers are sticking zeros in their water now, but you are dealing with ā€œextremeā€ heat at times inside pools

I’ve got a few friends that are definitely in the pro salt camp, always got cramp at the end of marathons, starting as early as 18 miles I think.

They were reaching 70+ mile weeks as well. I was always sceptical as it didn’t affect me and I was generally running quite a bit less.

But they seemed to improve when using lots of salt or other minerals :man_shrugging:t2:

I’ve always been pro magnesium for cramps but I get them mostly in my sleep rather than training or racing. I had a proper one once in RttKing and that’s not something I want to ever repeat!

1 Like

I swear by salt (in drink not tablets) but not for cramps but because my post salt performances were so much better than before & it balances the level of sweetness for the sugary calories required.

1 Like

Isn’t this how Andy Blow created his empire? :wink:

2 Likes

This says much the same:

No evidence salt / electrolytes work, except for the hundreds of use cases where they do work.

5 Likes

And back to overrated - Zone2 training.

5 Likes

Don’t you know anything, its all about zone 1 now :wink:

2 Likes

You might have the winner there.

I’ll take your salt and raise a pickle juice

2 Likes

Seems to help aborting them? Although for neurological reasons from the taste in the mouth rather than anything to do with salt absorption

1 Like

they can be…but not all electrolyte imbalances are fatigue related…

Yes, I did (when I trained / raced!)

A bit like Doka, there was just a marked improvement in performance when I did and didn’t take high salt PH. Cramps, or a perceived reduction in them, was a sort of side benefit I did observe. But base hydration just didn’t cut it for me. I still find even when not really training, that if I’m a bit dehydrated and drink water, it just flushes straight through and I’m peeing constantly. Add some salt and it seems to be retained and replenish the dehydration more effectively.

Placebo or not, I had the same effect with salt as I did with Maurten. When very fit, and no change or other differences in other aspects, taking one or the other, or not taking one, was a massive difference just in training performance. And so I carried that into races.

7 Likes

You trained with Maurten :open_mouth:?

Obviously a southerner :joy:.

7 Likes